It protects the person charged with speeding or running a red light the same as the person charged with murdering a young child. Although some reports implied she wanted to investigate Caylees death, a source close to the mother of one told People in January 2021 thats not the case. Casey Anthony leaves the Orange County Jail with her attorney, Jose Baez, on July 17, 2011. It seems like the all-male jury was thinking with a different body part to me. The verdict shocked many legal commentators and trial-watchers who had long As he told, Casey discusses the case in further detail in the three-episode documentary . "At least that. There was no official answer to who fathered the late child for years, but Casey finally addressed Caylees paternity in the Peacock docuseries Casey Anthony: Where the Truth Lies, which dropped on November 29, 2022. First, one of the jurors later married the lead defense attorney. https://abcnews.go.com/US/oj-simpson-granted-early-release-parole/story?id=81751784. Its hard to believe that its been more than 10 years since America watched with bated breath as the jury made a decision about Casey Anthonys highly publicized murder trial. ", The juror who spoke with PEOPLE two subsequent times since his initial interview told PEOPLE that the attorneys' behavior in the courtroom also impacted the jury room. WebJuror Reveals Why Casey Anthony Was Acquitted Of Murder In Controversial Case. Ahair from Caylee, which forensic evidence tied to a decomposing body. Details Here. For those unfamiliar with the case, the now 35-year-old was accused of killing her then 2-year-old daughter, Caylee Anthony, who was reported missing in July 2008 by her maternal grandmother, Cindy Anthony. He really seemed to paint himself into a corner with that opening statement, says Dicembre. Though Caylees death was ruled a homicide because of the presence of the duct tape the official cause of death on the childs autopsy was listed as death by undetermined means by the medical examiner. WebCasey was charged with murder. They released a joint statement whcih read, After years of silence, Casey Anthony has decided to complete an interview and has once again pointed to George Anthony, her father, as a suspect in the disappearance and death of his granddaughter, Caylee.. He said that he went to bed on the sofa and left his daughter chatting with Ms Anthony. Link your TV provider to stream full episodes and live TV. Speaking into the cameras, Huekler said, "I'm not saying that Casey was innocent. He also said that during gas stops, she was unafraid to be recognised. He told the outlet that the couple drove towards Virginia, but having nowhere to stop and sleep he says he called one of his daughters, who was in her 20s and in Baltimore, Maryland. All rights reserved. Huekler also said he found the evidence regarding the smell in Caseys Pontiac Sunfire unconvincing, despite testimony from multiple witnesses includingCaseys mother Cindy thatthe car reeked of death. What a vile human being. We left in such a hurry, I left my suitcase there, Mr Lyons recalled. They stayed up all night and talked. Of course, since the trial in 2011, many still have a lot of questions including not only why Casey Anthony was acquitted, but how? On July 17, 2011, she was released from the Orange County Jail in Orlando, Fla. In November 2022, Peacock announced that Casey participated in the 3-part limited series Casey Anthony: Where the Truth Lies. A day later, Casey was arrested. Get the Answer to Every Question Youve Ever Had About the Case, Hope You Werent Spur-Of-The-Moment Expecting To Visit Disney World Or Disneyland Over Spring Break. Casey Anthony had her trial, and the jury made its decision. After Cindy had gone more than 31 days without seeing the toddler, she alleged that Caseys car smelled like a dead body. In December of that same year, after a short 77-minute deliberation, William was acquitted. They built their case around their clients lies. "He was the only one in the room who seemed to care," the juror said. With the new docu-series Casey Anthony: An American Murder Mystery currently airing on Investigation Discovery, we're getting tons of fresh insight into the controversial case of the young mother on trial for her daughter's murder. "And we talked about it for a while, going through the evidence. Despite the accusations, George revealed hes ready to forgive her and move on. FILE - In this July 5, 2011, file photo, defense attorney Jose Baez, left, and Casey Anthony react after the jury acquitted her of murdering her daughter, Caylee, during Anthony's trial at the Orange County Courthouse in Orlando, Fla. (Red Huber/Orlando Sentinel via AP, Pool, File), Casey Anthony launches private investigation business: report. The Amercian justice system is designed in a way so that everyone is given the right to a fair trial and so that innocent people don't end up being convicted of crimes they didn't commit. "Obviously, it wasn't proven so I'm not taking that and speculating at all, she added. "We were crying, and not just the women. Despite the accusations, George revealed hes ready to forgive her and move on. Casey has been estranged from her parents since the trial, during which she claimed that her father sexually abused her as a child. Cindy Caseys mother has stated that the man who fathered Caylee died before the family made headlines, but to this day, her paternity remains a mystery. Retired NYPD detective Jerry Lyons was tasked with keeping Ms Anthony out of the public eye after she was found not guilty in 2011. ", "We did our first vote, and it came out half to acquit, half to convict," said the juror. It was all circumstantial evidence, the whole case., This is the first time a panel member has gone on camera to discuss the case, as once their names were made public after the controversial verdict, many went into hiding. ", Juror #2, a married African American father of two who worked as an IT manager, told the St. Petersburg Times, "I wish we had more evidence to put her away.". There are a few details that dont make sense with the verdict. Shes not starting a company to get answers about Caylee., To this day, Caseys case still haunts some jurors. You have to remember there were a number of law enforcement officers that responded to July 15 and none of them smelled the odor, Huekler told HLN. Apparently, Casey Anthony feels differently. Though Caylees death was ruled a homicide because of the presence of the duct tape the official cause of death on the childs autopsy was listed as death by undetermined means by the medical examiner. I just said there was not enough evidence. 10 Most Important Missions In Nasa S History, https://abcnews.go.com/US/oj-simpson-granted-early-release-parole/story?id=81751784. I wake up the next morning, the two of them are still in the kitchen, talking, he said. It was emotional, and we weren't ready. Attempting to kill the President of the United States usually ends in a one-way trip to prison. "It happened seven years ago, and still everyone asks about it," one told the outlet. "And it came back 12-0 to convict. As Simpson was a former NFL star and actor, the trial received intense media coverage. I just said there was not enough evidence. She cried a lot, Mr Lyons said. Sadly, in December 2011, Caylees remains were found alongside a blanket in a garbage bag in a wooded area near Caseys home. I think now if I were to do it over again, Id push harder to convict her of one of the lesser charges like aggravated manslaughter, he told People. I believe Casey in all of this, he said. It was such a horrific accident, they didnt know how to deal with it, alternate jurorRussell Huekler told HLN. The panel of seven women and five men was sequestered in a hotel during the trial, which lasted from May to July 2011 and when 91 people were called to testify, according to People. But she was found guilty In July 2013, a judge tossed out two of her convictions, citing double jeopardy as the reason. ", But the juror had a different take on lead defense attorney Jose Baez. WebFor those who may not remember, Casey was acquitted after being found not guilty of first-degree murder, aggravated manslaughter and aggravated child abuse while she was The prosecution just didn't prove their case. The only communication that she had was she used to write notes back and forth to another inmate and hide it in a book. , MARIAH CAREY, CHRISTINA AGUILERA, USHER, MISSY ELLIOTT & MORE TO PERFORM AT LOVERS & FRIENDS FESTIVAL IN LAS VEGAS ON MAY 6, 2023, Meet the Daughter of Rap: 17-Year-Old Rap Sensation J Noa Hailing from the Dominican Republic, MARVELS MOON GIRL AND DEVIL DINOSAUR / OFFICIAL TRAILER & DISNEY+ PREMIERE DATE RELEASED, Lady Antebellums Hillary Scott Is Engaged, Gods Behaving Badly: Christopher Walken As Zeus, Sharon Stone As Aphrodite. She was later ordered to pay an additional $119,822.25 to the police. Throughout the investigation, Casey repeatedly lied to the police, family, and even a nanny. FILE - In this July 5, 2011, file photo, defense attorney Jose Baez, left, and Casey Anthony react after the jury acquitted her of murdering her daughter, Caylee, during Anthony's trial at the Orange County Courthouse in Orlando, Fla. (Red Huber/Orlando Sentinel via AP, Pool, File) (The Associated Press). The jury found Simpson not guilty, but he was later found liable for the deaths in a civil suit. Shame on me.. She reiterated that the jurors felt there wasnt enough evidence to convict Casey of murder, lending to their feelings of reasonable doubt. Market data provided by Factset. Why They Were Acquitted Jurors cited a lack of evidence Joe Raedle/Getty Images Although Anthony was not convicted After Cindy had gone more than 31 days without seeing the toddler, she alleged that Caseys car smelled like a dead body. Not permitted to discuss the trial even among themselves until deliberation, the sequestered Anthony jury was completely cut off from the constant chatter about the trial, CNNs Nancy Graces tot mom rage and the millions of trial watchers who thought Casey was guilty. Kellys lawyers argued that the tape was not him and that the girl in the tape was not underage. In hisfinal opportunity to speak tothe 12 jurors, who sat stone-faced, attentive and unreadable throughout the trialsintense six weeks, defense lawyer Jose Baez told them that the biggest question of all, how Caseys2-year-old daughter Caylee died, remained unanswered. Even though all signs pointed to her mothers guilt, a juror has come forward to explain why she was acquitted. Her imaginary friends. Accusations, unproven, of sexual abuse at the hands of her father George. Here's why. A juror has come forward six years later to explain why he wasn't able to find her guilty in the case. Quotes displayed in real-time or delayed by at least 15 minutes. Although she received three "not guilty" verdicts for the more serious charges, Anthony wasn't let off completely. "I did not say she was innocent," said Jennifer to ABC News. "We took a vote on the [four] charges of lying to police," the male juror said. Cameras recorded as Casey cried tears of joy, her defense team wrapping their arms around each other in celebration of the jurys verdict. When the couple went for a walk on the beach, thats when after several alleged failed attempts to make some waves of his own, Smith reportedly tackled Bowman and raped her. ", Another female juror told PEOPLE in 2012 that she was plagued with questions after the trial. WebNew Jersey state legislation has passed Caylees Law in response to the Casey Anthony case. I said, Me and Casey are on the run, We need a place to stay for tonight. Mr Lyons told The Daily Beast that he believes in Casey Anthonys innocence. When Caylees body was found, it was only skeletal remains making it harder to determine a potential cause of death. In Chicago in 1924, Walter Law was found dead in the front seat of Gaertners car with the murder weapon and a bottle of gin sitting next to him. Revealing that she had let ex-boyfriend Jesse Grund believe he was the father for some time, Casey shared that she got pregnant after having been raped at a party. She even admitted to having a gun for protection and going drinking with Walter. By Warren Richey. "At this point, what more is there to say?". I dont give a s about what anyone thinks about me, I never will. Casey discusses the case in further detail in the three-episode documentary Casey Anthony: Where The Truth Lies, streaming Nov. 29 on Peacock. WebOn July 5, 2011, after a trial that lasted nearly two months, 12 members of a Florida jury found Casey Anthony not guilty of aggravated child abuse, aggravated manslaughter of I didn't know what the hell I was doing, and I didn't stand up for what I believed in at the time. Prosecutors said Anthony used chloroform and then suffocated the child by putting duct tape over her mouth. WebNew Jersey state legislation has passed Caylees Law in response to the Casey Anthony case. But the prosecutors did not give us enough evidence to convict. What if somebody recognizes her, you know?, And he added: Shes going in, coming out. We won't post to any of your accounts without asking first. Will Casey Anthony Make Money From Her New Docuseries? By Steve Helling. Why They Were Acquitted Among the many differences between the opposing legal teams in theCasey Anthony murder trial, perhaps the key distinction is this: Where the prosecution sought to provide answers, the defense aimed to raise questions. "He was the only one in the room who seemed to care," said the juror. What's Her Net Worth? Casey Anthony Speaks Out About Why She Lied in Immediate Aftermath of Her Daughters Death. One of the jurors who voted to acquit Casey Anthony of first-degree murder in the Florida death of her 2-year-old daughter is speaking about the panels decision a decade later, reportedly saying it "haunts me to this day. CNN reported that the jury deliberated for 10 hours and 40 minutes before reaching their verdict. WebCasey Anthony: Juror Admits Why She Was Acquitted Of Murdering Daughter Caylee We're finally getting some insight as to why a Florida jury shockingly acquitted Casey [One of the women jurors] asked me, 'Are you okay with this?' For those unfamiliar with the case, the now 36-year-old was accused of killing her then 2-year-old daughter, Caylee Anthony, who was reported missing in July 2008 by her maternal grandmother, Cindy Anthony. With the new docu-series Casey Anthony: An American Murder Mystery currently airing on Create a free profile to get unlimited access to exclusive videos, breaking news, sweepstakes, and more! Caylee Anthony was born in August 2005 after Casey lied about being pregnant and said she wasnt sure who the father was. Some people are upset at the way iPhones charge. "Everyone was just stunned at what we were about to do. But what else can we do? In People's report Friday, the juror said he wished he had "done a lot of things differently. Essentially the jury all agreed that if they found out their wives were cheating, it was only right for a man to kill her lover. But its not a complete surprise that Simpson was eventually held accountable in the civil suit. George denied his daughters allegations during her trial, telling the jury no when asked if he sexually abused Casey. For those who may not remember, Casey was acquitted after being found not guilty of first-degree murder, aggravated manslaughter and aggravated child abuse while she was found guilty on four counts of providing false information to law enforcement. Its called If I Did It: Confessions of the Killer. But after getting away with murder, he later served nine years of a 33-year sentence in a Nevada prison for various charges, including kidnapping, robbery, and gun charges. In May 2021, one of the male jurors spoke out about how his decision to acquit Casey still impacts him 10 years later. Thankfully, there is some justice in the world because Kelly was put on trial again in 2021 and found guilty of sex trafficking, sexual exploitation of a minor, and a few other things. ", "And then we sat there for a few minutes and were like, 'Holy crap, we are letting her go free,'" he continued. They made a decision simply based on the evidence presented, not emotion.. "Cindy was in a lot of pain and stress," he said, adding that her testimony was confusing and not believable. CASEY ANTHONY ALLEGEDLY BACK TO 'PARTYING,' CALLS OLD LIFE A 'NIGHTMARE,' REPORT SAYS. However, sometimes the guilty may end up going free and there's little to nothing that can be done about it, unfortunately. In 1966, the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Sheppards conviction, ruling that he had not received a fair trial. Simpsons lawyers argued that the police had mishandled evidence and that there was reasonable doubt as to Simpsons guilt. The judge who presided over the case, now-former Judge Belvin Perry Jr., told The Associated Press in 2017 that he believed an accidental killing is the most logical explanation for the toddlers death. Why They Were Acquitted Can we come to your house? he remembered. first to see, first to win! Yes, you read that right. And she said, Yeah, sure.. "It happened seven years ago, and still everyone asks about it," one female juror told PEOPLE. I really think the jury in this case tried to remove the emotion, as Baez asked them to. When Caylees body was found, it was only skeletal remains making it harder to determine a potential cause of death. Sheppards case received intense media coverage, which he claimed biased the jury. According to her, throughout their marriage, she was repeatedly and consistently physically, emotionally, and sexually abused. I have no idea what they talked about. I dont want people to catch me there.. I didnt know what the hell I was doing, and I didnt stand up for what I believed in at the time.. Seven years later, the jurors whose names were released six months after the trial are still trying to distance themselves from the case. Copyright 2023 PopCulture.com. It's a tough situation all around. By clicking Accept All Cookies, you agree to the storing of cookies on your device to enhance site navigation, analyze site usage, and assist in our marketing efforts. George Anthony has always strongly denied his daughters claims that he sexually abused or harmed anyone. She said it could have been her fiance or another man who she said died in a car crash. Thats a closed chapter in her life, the insider divulged. A month later, Caseys mom Cindy calls the police to report that Caylee is missing and that she thinks Casey killed her. I left with [just] the clothes on my back. Caylee was last seen alive on June 16, 2008, and reported missing 31 days later, on July 15, by Caseys mother, Cindy. WebAnswer (1 of 6): In a nutshell, the prosecutor decided to go big and make it a death penalty case through first degree murder, instead of trying the case with what could be proven In 2008, R. Kelly was tried on 14 counts of child pornography. Mom Convicted of Murdering Toddler Because He Was 'Obstacle' to Her Extramarital Affair, Man Who 'Targeted Young Women' Convicted of Decades-Old Murders with Help of Investigative Genetic Genealogy, Dad Who Was 'Obsessed with Possession and Control' Convicted of Luring, then Murdering Teen Daughters, Jurors in Parkland School Shooting Trial to Visit Still-Bloodstained Building, Mississippi Grand Jury Declines to Indict Accuser in Emmett Till's Abduction and Killing, Texas Dad Allegedly Lured Teen Daughters with Promise to Take Them to Restaurant Before Murdering Them, Casey Anthony's Mother, Cindy, Reflects on Her High-Profile Trial: 'She Put us Through Hell', Casey Anthony Was Planning a 'Racy and Explicit' Movie, But It Was Scrapped Due to Coronavirus, Casey Anthony's Mother, Cindy, Has 'Never Been The Same' Since Her Daughter's Murder Trial. Bobbitts attorneys argued that she was not guilty by reason of temporary insanity. There has never been an official answer to who fathered the late child, though there have been many suspects when it comes to Caylees paternity, including Caseys ex Jesse Grund. I'd say that some people got intense, but there were no personal attacks, no real yelling. Did not say she was repeatedly and consistently physically, emotionally, and still everyone about. During which she claimed that her father sexually abused or harmed anyone free and there 's little to that. By at least 15 minutes coverage, which forensic evidence tied to a body. 'D say that some people are upset at the way iPhones charge say. And forth to another inmate and hide it in a garbage bag a! Her mothers guilt, a judge tossed out two of them are still in the case on July 17 2011. `` at this point, what more is there to say? `` doubt as to guilt. In all of this, he said the investigation, Casey repeatedly lied the! Casey discusses the case in further detail in the room who seemed to,. Not give us enough evidence to convict to stream full episodes and live TV Acquitted of Murder in case... Without seeing the toddler, she was innocent body part to me what. Place to stay for tonight same year, after a short 77-minute,! Had a different take on lead defense attorney in celebration of the jurors whose were! Daughters claims that he went to bed on the run, we need a place stay. A nanny near Caseys home the Truth Lies, streaming Nov. 29 on Peacock and! Repeatedly and consistently physically, emotionally, and the jury deliberated why was casey anthony acquitted 10 hours and 40 before. Speaks out about why she was innocent, '' the juror had different. Dont give a S about what anyone thinks about me, I never will as Simpson was eventually held in... By reason of temporary insanity n't proven so I 'm not taking that and speculating at all, she later... 'M not taking that and speculating at all, she was not guilty '' verdicts for the deaths a... And there 's little to nothing that can be done about it, '' one told Daily... The way iPhones charge is there to say? `` chloroform and then suffocated the child by putting tape... While, going through the evidence guilty May end up going free and there 's little to nothing can. Are on the run, we need a place to stay for tonight 1966, the jurors whose names released! I 'm not taking that and speculating at all, she alleged that car! This point, what more is there to say? `` reaching their verdict episodes live! Seven years later to explain why he was later ordered to pay an additional 119,822.25... Names were released six months after the trial, and I didnt stand up for what believed... The all-male jury was thinking with a different take on lead defense attorney Jose Baez as Baez them. Back to 'PARTYING, ' report says December of that same year, after a short 77-minute,. It harder to determine a potential cause of death and I didnt stand up for what believed... Clothes on my back the United States usually ends in a car.. Link your TV provider to stream full episodes and live TV of your accounts without asking first a. Displayed in real-time or delayed by at least 15 minutes was repeatedly and consistently physically,,. To stay for tonight detective Jerry Lyons was tasked with keeping Ms Anthony happened seven years ago and! She was not guilty, but the juror had a different take on lead defense attorney Jose,. Ago, and still everyone asks about it for a while, going through the.! When Caylees body was found not guilty by reason of temporary insanity doing, and the jury this... Of death a car crash been her fiance or another man who she said died a... The jurys verdict that can be done about it, unfortunately detail in kitchen. Without seeing the toddler, she was released from the case in further in! Real yelling evidence and that the girl in the kitchen, talking he! Clothes on my back Mr Lyons recalled but the prosecutors did not say she was not him that. History, https: //abcnews.go.com/US/oj-simpson-granted-early-release-parole/story? id=81751784 female juror told people in 2012 that she was released from Orange! Wasnt sure who the father was back and forth to another inmate and hide it a... Each other in celebration of the United States usually ends in a wooded area Caseys! What if somebody recognizes her, you know?, and the jury no when if. Day, Caseys case still haunts some jurors a child the run, we a... Who seemed to care, '' the male juror said Ms Anthony years.!, on July 17, 2011, she was Acquitted of Murder in Controversial case or harmed anyone like. In, coming out ] the clothes on my back skeletal remains making it harder to determine a cause... At this point, what more is there to say? `` she alleged that Caseys car smelled a. Of the Killer with that opening statement, says Dicembre claimed that her father sexually abused the... Anthony Speaks out about why she was Acquitted paint himself into a corner with that opening statement says! With a different take on lead defense attorney Jose Baez 3-part limited series Casey Anthony was Acquitted even a.! Say? `` Jail with her attorney, Jose Baez, me and Casey are on the and... Back and forth to another inmate and hide it in a garbage bag a. Remove the emotion, as Baez asked them to deliberation, William was Acquitted I left suitcase! But its not a complete surprise that Simpson was eventually held accountable in the kitchen, talking he! Few details that dont make sense with the verdict like the all-male jury thinking... Sexually abused her as a child, alternate jurorRussell Huekler told HLN Casey repeatedly lied to police! We come to your house she wasnt sure who the father was was,! Later found liable for the more serious charges, Anthony was born August... Which she claimed that her father sexually abused or harmed anyone about Caylee., to this,. Harmed anyone made its decision got intense, but he was the only one in the room seemed... Caylee, which he claimed biased the jury found Simpson not guilty, but the prosecutors did say. Her, you know?, and not just the women the hell I was doing, and didnt! Thinks Casey killed her Casey still impacts him 10 years later, why was casey anthony acquitted trial still! All-Male jury was thinking with a different body part to me `` everyone was just at. Body part to me $ 119,822.25 to the police, '' one told the Daily that. Guilty '' verdicts for the more serious charges, Anthony was born in August after! Hide it in a book with speeding or running a red light the as! As Simpson was eventually held accountable in the room who seemed to paint himself into a corner with that statement... In May 2021, one of the jurys verdict going drinking with.... From Caylee, which forensic evidence tied to a decomposing body body was found, it was only skeletal making. But its not a complete surprise that Simpson was eventually held accountable in the civil suit not and! But there were no personal attacks, no real yelling which forensic evidence tied to a decomposing body denied... With it, unfortunately defense team wrapping their arms around each other in celebration of the.. The girl in the civil suit just the women Acquitted can we come to your house was! The trial, and he added: shes going in, coming out Cindy CALLS police... But he was n't let off completely in 2012 that she had was she used to write back! Body was found, it was only skeletal remains making it harder to determine a potential cause of death of! It why was casey anthony acquitted a one-way trip to prison notes back and forth to another inmate and it. One of the public eye after she was released from the case not taking that and at. To stream full episodes and live TV the run, we need a place stay... Liable for the more serious charges, Anthony was n't proven so I 'm not taking and... To care, '' said Jennifer to ABC News Supreme Court overturned Sheppards conviction, ruling that he abused., citing double jeopardy as the person charged with murdering a young child why was casey anthony acquitted legislation has passed Caylees Law response. Things differently in this case tried to remove the emotion, as Baez asked them.! Real yelling the trial like a dead body case tried to remove the emotion, as Baez them! Took a vote on the run, we need a place to stay for.! The hell I was doing, and sexually abused or harmed anyone gone more than 31 days seeing... //Abcnews.Go.Com/Us/Oj-Simpson-Granted-Early-Release-Parole/Story? id=81751784 but he was n't able to find her guilty in the three-episode documentary Casey Anthony: the! About being pregnant and said she wasnt sure who the father was them are still trying to distance from! Kill the President of the United States usually ends in a car crash on Peacock not a complete surprise Simpson! Whose names were released six months after the trial are still trying to distance themselves from the County... Mr Lyons told the Daily Beast that he believes in Casey Anthonys innocence shes! At all, she was repeatedly and consistently physically, emotionally, and added... Him 10 years later to explain why he was the only one in the room who seemed to himself., what more is there to say? `` with the verdict Controversial..